EMU: economy and rates are still braking ...
In recent months the activities in Eurozone have worsened due to the global financial crisis and in particular, due to the consequent weakening of exports, especially to the U.S. and emerging markets. Difficulties also in the property sector.
Spain, Ireland, Portugal and Greece are under stress for some time, but recent data have indicated a sharp deterioration also in Germany, France and, of course, Italy.
The economic downturn will continue for much of 2009, however, differently to what probably will happen in the U.S. and UK, companies and families in Eurozone not have to suffer a prolonged deleveraging and also will begin to benefit for a lower inflation, which should continue to decline (if oil will allow that ...).
In this context, as you know, on 15th January the ECB cut rates from 2.5% to 2% (back to the lowest of 2003 and 2005, when only 3 months ago they were still 4.25%) and, moreover, could further reduce it, although not immediately, to 1%, according to many analysts.
But the ECB seems to fear the ZIRP
What is surprising today, however, is the quite different (and slower) speed of reaction of the Central Bank in Frankfurt viz-à-viz the U.S. Fed, which is typical symptom of a less willingness to adopt a policy of zero interest rates (ZIRP) .
Is good? If you look upon the cross EUR / USD the answer should be negative, given that the market is punishing the European currency, betting, therefore, a greater potential for recovery in the U.S. compared to Eurozone.
But the Euro is suffering also against other currencies, losing 7% against the Swiss franc and 5% against the Yen just last month. In the last 2 weeks, finally, it has lost 8% against the sterling pound, which had marked at 98 pence on December 30th last year, records of all time.
Looking to other aspects, however, seems increasingly anachronistic the attempt of the ECB President, Jean-Claude Trichet, to defend its mandate to fight inflation, arguing that this still leads to greater stability for those countries, such as Italy, that before the Euro suffered in particular for the growth of prices.
I refer specifically to the continued widening of the spread of return on bonds issued by countries less "virtuous" in relation both to the rates of German government bonds, which reached the highest levels since the Euro was created, and to the interbank short-term rates (for which, however, one can truly claim the so called 'euroconvergence")
This - it's important to be clear - is in fact another brake on the European recovery, as it reduces the leeway of the governments plans for any fiscal stimulus. And not only for the much-criticized Italy, of course, but also for many other countries, for example, Spain, where the deficit is expected to reach 6% of GDP, Ireland (7.2%) and Portugal (3.3%). It's no coincidence that the credit rating agency Standard & Poor's recently downgraded Greece (from A to A-) and put under observation the AAA rating of Spain and that of other countries such as Austria and Ireland.
Government bond at risk
While inflation will remain probably low for a long time, and so the short-term rates, I think we will see a gradual rise in bond yields (which push the prices down) over the next 12 months.
The rate cuts made by the Central Bank will not be many, the issue of government bond is expected to increase during the remainder of 2009 and economic activity will begin a phase of recovery. Not least, sooner or later, the tendency to make only safe investments will decline, leaving room for a greater propensity to take risks.
As mentioned elsewhere, government bonds seem to have less appeal from a fundamental point-of-view and, therefore, more and more risk (almost a contradiction, for those who still consider them always the "risk-free" alternative!).
Have good weekend
Original post: Tassi BCE in calo, ma per quanto?